Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: Balance Shaft Removal, How, Why or Why Not!

  1. #1

    Join Date

    Washington State

    1986 Mitsubishi Mighty Max


    Balance Shaft Removal, How, Why or Why Not!

    Balance Shaft Removal
    1. Introduction
    Balance shafts are commonly found in inline four cylinder engines such as the Mitsubishi 4G63 which, due to the asymmetry of their design, have an inherent second order vibration (vibrating at twice the engine RPM) which, contrary to popular belief, cannot be eliminated no matter how well the internal components are balanced. This vibration is generated because the movement of the connecting rods in an inline engine is not symmetrical throughout the crankshaft rotation; thus during a given period of crankshaft rotation, the descending and ascending pistons are not always completely opposed in their acceleration, giving rise to a net vertical inertial force twice in each revolution whose intensity increases quadratically with RPM, no matter how closely the components are matched for weight.

    The 4G63 found in are equipped with 2 balance shafts. The left balance shaft that's directly connected to the oil pump driven gear and the right balance shaft that's driven by the balance shaft belt over the oil pump sprocket. Two balance shafts rotate in opposite directions at twice engine speed. Equally sized eccentric weights on these shafts are sized and phased so that the inertial reaction to their counter-rotation cancels out in the horizontal plane, but adds in the vertical plane, giving a net force equal to but 180 degrees out of phase with the undesired second-order vibration of the basic engine, thereby canceling it. The basic problem presented by the concept is adequately supporting and lubricating a part rotating at twice engine speed at the higher RPMs where the second order vibration becomes unacceptable.

    So why do it? The main reason for balance shaft elimination should be reliability as power gains are minimal. As you can see it inherits a potent lubrication problem and unlike the name suggests it's job isn't to balance but merely masks off the vibrations. Silent shaft is a more appropriate term but not used as commonly. Although the chances are slim, it's still one less part that can fail.

    The Good
    ⦁ More HP to the wheels
    ⦁ Zero chance the balance shaft belt will fail and kill the timing belt
    ⦁ Zero chance the balance shaft bearings will fail and damage the rest of the motor
    ⦁ More oil pressure to the rest of the motor

    The Bad
    ⦁ More vibration is felt in side the car (no more is made, just more is felt)
    ⦁ More oil pressure to the rest of the motor, which is usually too much. Extra work to get the oil pressure back in spec.

    2. Parts Required

    MD098626 Stub shaft to replace the left balance shaft
    MD040597 Right balance shaft front bearing used to block the oil galley¹
    MD103722 Right balance shaft rear bearing used to block the oil galley¹
    MD092785 Plug to block off the right balance shaft provision on the front case
    MD128107 Spacer to replace the crank shaft sprocket B²
    MF140022 8 x 14 bolt to replace the balancer belt tensioner (any bolt will do)
    *1 You can use your existing bearing if you're able to pull them out without damaging it.
    *2 This is optional but recommended.
    * Same parts apply to all 6-bolt, 7-bolt

    3. Balance Shaft Removal
    Front case removal

    Name:  1.gif
Views: 1899
Size:  24.0 KB
    Remove the plug bolt located under the 3rd cylinder freeze plug about 2 inches above the oil pan. Inset a Phillips screwdriver with a shank diameter of 8mm (.32 in.) into the plug hole to lock the balance shaft.

    Name:  2.gif
Views: 1876
Size:  20.6 KB
    Check to be sure that the screwdriver goes in 60 mm (2.36 in.) or more. If the screwdriver will only go in 20 - 25 mm (.79-.98 in.) before striking the counterbalance shaft, turn the sprocket once and check that the screwdriver goes in 60 mm (2.36 in.) or more. This will lock the balance shaft and prevent the oil pump sprocket and driven gear from spinning while loosening the nut/bolt. Remove the oil pump sprocket.

    Name:  3.gif
Views: 1894
Size:  32.4 KB
    Remove the castle plug. The special tool isn't much help since it slips off when torque is applied. Just tap the teeth with a blunt end to break it loose. Remove the underlying O-ring in the front case groove.

    Name:  4.gif
Views: 1788
Size:  30.0 KB
    Remove the driven gear bolt that secures the oil pump driven gear to the left balance shaft. Remove all accessories on the front case and remove the front case from the cylinder block. NOTE : If the front case sticks to the block pry over the M10 bolt where the flange is the thickest. Cover the crank shaft key with a cloth to prevent damage to the oil seal when pulling out the front case.

    Right balance shaft oil feed

    Name:  5.gif
Views: 1672
Size:  19.7 KB
    Name:  6.gif
Views: 1689
Size:  8.0 KB
    Oil is fed to the right balance shaft from the main oil galley. The bearing is installed with the clinch positioned at 12:00 and the oil hole to the right so that it aligns with the main oil galley opening.

    4. Balance shaft bearing install

    Name:  7.jpg
Views: 1673
Size:  24.7 KB
    Install the bearings flipped 180 degrees at the vertical axis to block off the oil hole. You can see the bearing oil hole is now to the left. NOTE: Install the rear first. You can use the balance shaft's front end since it has a larger diameter than the rear bearing.

    Name:  8.jpg
Views: 1771
Size:  33.6 KB
    The left balance shaft bearing can be eliminated since the oil is fed through the shaft and not from the block.

    5. Stub shaft install

    Name:  9.jpg
Views: 1740
Size:  36.0 KB
    Use red Loctite or equivalent!
    Install the stub shaft to the oil pump driven gear and torque the driven gear bolt to 25-29 ft. lbs.
    Install the oil pump gears so that the timing mark are shown. You can opt to pack the space with petroleum jelly to build oil pressure faster when priming the engine.
    Install the oil pump cover and torque to 11-13 ft. lbs. The cover is installed dry without any gasket.
    NOTE: Since we're eliminating the balance shaft there's no need to align the timing marks on the pump gears.

    6. Front case plug install

    Name:  10.jpg
Views: 1720
Size:  29.6 KB
    Remove the front case oil seal (red arrow) and install the rubber lined plug in it's place. The black arrow on the front case is where the balance shaft belt tensioner bolts to. The tensioner is replaced with a shorter 8x14 bolt.
    NOTE: Most recommend the use of sealant at the plug and bolt flange. At the plug I never had a problem, when reusing an old front case I had oil seeping through the bolt. Above and below the bolt is where the oil passages are so I placed a 1" O.D washer under the bolt and it took care of the problem. The washer used in the tensioner arm works great.

    Name:  11.gif
Views: 1735
Size:  8.7 KB
    Install a new gasket and lube the crank oil seal and temporarily bolt the front case to the block. Mount the oil filter housing with a new gasket and torque all M8 bolts to 14-16 ft. lbs.
    NOTE: The M10 bolt in the red circle should be tightened at a torque of 20-25 ft. lbs. Install the castle plug and torque to 14-20 ft. lbs. Don't forget to install the O-ring on the front case groove, you risk cracking the front case if you torque the castle plug without it. Install the oil pump sprocket after lubricating the oil seal and torque the nut 36-43 ft. lbs. This should be done before installing the oil pan as there's no easy way to lock the sprocket with the balance shaft gone.

    7. Crank shaft sprocket spacer

    Name:  12.jpg
Views: 1680
Size:  36.7 KB
    The spacer also goes in place of the crank shaft sprocket "B" that would have been spinning meaninglessly without the balancer belt. Not really needed, but it weighs 2oz which shaves 8.7oz off the rotating assembly. Not bad for $7.
    Put everything back on, time the belt and you're done.
    With the added vibration, I strongly suggest you clamp the oil filter to prevent it from coming loose.

    Removing the balance shaft without pulling the motor
    1. Remove timing belt, downpipe, transfer case and oil pan.
    2. Remove alternator, power steering pump, cross member, front and left motor mount to drop the engine low enough.
    3. Remove the front case with the left balance shaft attached. This involves pulling the crank shaft sprocket and everything else over the front case.
    4. This is all done laying on your back with oil dripping on your face.

    Ebay Balance Shaft Elimination kits
    Stay away from the no-name Ebay BSE kits that provide you with a steel non-rubber lined plug and a stub shaft without an oil groove.
    Another balance shaft elimination using a full shaft instead of the stub shaft
    There are vendors that machine off the left balance shaft's counter weights or provide you with a billet shaft so you have a full shaft rotating instead of using the short stub shaft. Theory is, a stub shaft without the support provided by the rear bearing journal allows the oil pump gears to push apart and wear into the aluminum pump. Eventually resulting in the oil pump seizing. Don't let the oil pump run dry and you won't have a problem.

    Balance Shafts - To Be or Not To Be?

    Keep Your Balance Shafts
    By Jack's Transmissions
    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	JacksTransmissionslogo.jpg 
Views:	75 
Size:	25.9 KB 
ID:	10952

    If you are considering an engine or 60k service from us please also consider leaving the balance shafts in your engine. We have created this page to allow YOU to make an educated decision involving your balance shafts.

    We are not a company which caters to the 1% which want a car built to run in the single digits. We cater to the average person and many road racers. Those of us who want a car that we can drive every day and then take it to the track for some fun is what we are all about. Due to this we have become very successful and what we do seems to work quite well. We don't break any records because that's not what we do. We just build cars which will work and live a very long service life.

    Due to the fact that our customers are just average people, we want them to have an engine which they will love. A smooth engine on the street is a very nice thing to have and many customers appreciate this. Most builders don't care about the comfort factor, or your clutch and trans, so they will build you the same loud and buzzy engine for the car that is daily driven as they do for their race cars. We don't believe this is appropriate.

    You are free to make your own decisions. We are not forcing anyone to do anything and are more than happy to build anything you want, but please think twice before you decide to have us remove your balance shafts as you may not like what it will do to your car.

    Please continue reading this article at the link shown below, we insist... is not responsible for the information given here as the truth or that this modification will not damage your vehicle in any way. We place this information here only because of request made by and for our members for this service. We are not liable for damages that may occur from removal of your vehicles balance shafts and we gathered and posted the information for removal and for maintaining balance shafts for your own information. We insist on you reading further about this type of engine modification and make a decision that is all your own. With that said, "Happy Motoring".

  2. #2

    Join Date

    New Orleans, LA

    1995 Mitsubishi Mighty Max

    Just did this on my spare 2.4. Was very simple. I've seen far more engines destroyed from balance shafts than I have seen destroyed because they didn't have balance shafts.

    And balance shaft failures plague MANY 4 cylinder engines.

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts